Even Finish Masks Volatile Year For U.S. Economy

Dec 30, 2011
Originally published on December 30, 2011 4:16 pm

2011 was a year of crisis and revolution, and that took a big toll on the world's financial markets. In the United States, stocks lurched along for much of the year, losing and gaining ground over and over again.

Stock prices are ending the year just about where they were at the beginning, and anyone who invested in anything but the bluest of blue chip stocks probably didn't make much money. And yet, the flat trend lines masked a huge amount of volatility, says Jack Ablin, chief investment officer of Harris Private Bank.

"In many respects, this last year is sort of a microcosm of the last decade in that we've gone up and down and ended up sideways," Ablin says. "[There was] a lot of emotion — a big roller coaster — and end to end, we're not going very far," Ablin says.

Like 2008, this was a year when the stock market had more than its share of stomach-churning days of the Dow Jones industrial average rising or falling by triple digits. This year, what sent the market into a tailspin often took place overseas.

"There was an awful lot for the markets to deal with this year, and that did cause an awful lot of volatility in the market and ... some big slumps," says David Kelly, chief market strategist for J.P. Morgan Funds.

A Tumultuous Year In Review

In March, Japan was struck by a deadly earthquake and tsunami that slowed the country's industrial base to a crawl. Because a lot of parts for cars, cameras and television sets are manufactured in Japan, the impact was felt around the world — including in the United States, where auto sales dropped off. Meanwhile, the debt crisis that has plagued Europe for two years intensified.

In Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and Libya, protesters succeeded in driving longtime autocrats out of power, but the chaos and uncertainty drove oil prices higher.

Gold and U.S. Treasury debt were also up. But in August, Standard & Poor's downgraded U.S. debt for the first time after a crippling fight over whether Congress should raise the debt ceiling. President Obama was one of many who warned that the stalemate in Washington would have negative consequences.

"It's pretty likely that the uncertainty surrounding the raising of the debt ceiling for both businesses and consumers has been unsettling and just one more impediment to the full recovery that we need," Obama said in a speech in August.

But the debt markets seemed to shrug off the downgrade, and the interest on U.S. debt kept falling. Investors didn't seem all that worried about the U.S. fiscal picture, according to David Kelly.

"It's not like Standard & Poor's told investors anything they didn't already know, so when [they] downgraded the United States, that really didn't change people's perception of the creditworthiness of the U.S. government," Kelly says. "[And] then the Federal Reserve stepped in to say, 'We're going to support low interest rates in a variety of other ways.' "

Closely Tied To The World Economy

With all the threats hanging over the economy right now, U.S. Treasury debt still seems like a safe haven. And as Europe heads toward what looks like a recession, the clouds are parting a bit in the United States.

"There's starting to be somewhat of a disconnect: We're getting good, solid economic numbers here at home," says Ablin with Harris Private Bank. "They're still having their issues, they're still having their meetings and they're still having their debates."

But Ablin says as the New Year approaches, there are still big threats out there that keep him up at night. One is China, which has benefited from an enormous infrastructure boom.

"Sure, they need roads, they need bridges, they need trains, they need airports, but I'm not sure they need all of the construction that's been going on, and they're obviously building towers that are empty," he says. "Eventually that's going to catch up with them."

And a big slowdown in China would be felt in all the countries that sell it products and commodities, including the United States. The U.S. has become more closely tied to the world economy than ever, and as the events of this year have underscored all too well, what happens overseas can have a big impact on money that's invested at home.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel. 2011 was a year of crisis and revolution and took a big toll on the world's financial markets. In the U.S., stock prices lurched along for much of the year, losing and gaining ground over and over again.

It was the year that saw the first downgrade of U.S. debt by a major ratings company, but investors kept pouring money into U.S. treasuries and interest rates fell to historic lows.

NPR's Jim Zarroli has this look back at a tumultuous year.

JIM ZARROLI, BYLINE: Stock prices are ending the year just about where they began and anyone who invested in anything but the bluest of blue chip stocks probably didn't make much money. And yet the flat trend lines mask a huge amount of volatility, says Jack Ablin, chief investment officer at Harris Private Bank.

JACK ABLIN: In many respects, this last year is sort of microcosm of the last decade in that we've gone up and down and ended up sideways and, you know, a lot of emotion, a big rollercoaster, but end to end, we're not going very far.

ZARROLI: Like 2008, this was a year when the stock market had more than its share of stomach turning days when the Dow Jones industrial average rose or fell by triple digits.

And this year, what sent the market into a tailspin often took place overseas. In March, Japan was struck by a deadly earthquake and tsunami that slowed the country's industrial base to a crawl. And because a lot of parts for cars and cameras and television sets are manufactured in Japan, the impact was felt around the world. That included the United States, where auto sales dropped off.

Meanwhile, the debt crisis that has plagued Europe for two years intensified. In Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and Libya, protesters succeeded in driving longtime autocrats out of power, but the chaos and uncertainty drove oil prices up. In August, Standard and Poor's downgraded U.S. debt for the first time after a crippling fight over whether Congress should raise the debt ceiling.

But the debt markets seemed to shrug off the downgrade and the interest on U.S. debt kept falling. Investors didn't seem all that worried about the U.S. fiscal picture, says David Kelly, chief market strategist for J.P. Morgan funds.

DAVID KELLY: It's not like Standard and Poor's told investors anything they didn't already know, so when Standard and Poor's downgraded the United States, that really didn't change people's perception of the credit-worthiness of the U.S. government, and of course, then the Federal Reserve stepped in to say, we're going to support low interest rates in a variety of other ways.

ZARROLI: With all of the threats hanging over the economy right now, U.S. Treasury debt still seems like a safe haven. And as Europe heads toward what looks like a recession, the clouds are parting a bit in the United States. Again, Jack Ablin.

ABLIN: There's starting to be somewhat of a disconnect. We're getting good, solid economic numbers here at home. They're still having their issues. They're still having their meetings and they're still having their debates.

ZARROLI: But Ablin says, as the new year approaches, there are still big threats out there that keep him up at night. One is China, which has benefited from an enormous infrastructure boom.

ABLIN: They need roads, they need bridges, they need trains, they need airports. But I'm not sure they need all of the construction that's been going on and they're obviously building towers that are empty. Eventually, that's going to catch up with them.

ZARROLI: And a big slowdown in China would be felt in all of the countries that sell its products and commodities, including the United States. The U.S. has become more closely tied to the world economy than ever, and as the events of this year have underscored all too well, what happens overseas can have a big impact on money that's invested at home.

Jim Zarroli, NPR News, New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.