Negotiating The College Funding Labyrinth

Apr 24, 2012
Originally published on April 25, 2012 8:16 am

Now that your child has gotten into college, have you figured out how much it's actually going to cost — and who's going to pay for it?

These questions are hitting college-bound students and their parents right about now, along with the other million questions that nobody seems to have straight answers for. Paying for college can be complicated, if not mind-boggling.

Roughly 7 out of 10 students borrow money to pay for college, and for many, the process might as well be a mystery wrapped in a riddle.

Tom McWilliams, a psychology and computer science major at George Washington University, is paying about $60,000 a year for tuition, room and board.

"Right now I have about $6,000 a semester," McWilliams says. "I think it's all federal."

That's unlikely, because the most you can borrow from Uncle Sam is $10,000 a year, which means he's probably borrowing from a private lender and doesn't know it or can't tell the difference. In fact, McWilliams isn't entirely sure what types of loans he's taken out — federal, private, subsidized, unsubsidized.

"Actually, I don't remember," he laughs. McWilliams seems to take some strange pleasure, though, in knowing he's not alone.

"This is an expensive school, so a lot of people have debt here," he says. "They don't look too deeply into [the cost or debt], they just take the money."

That's the problem. When students get into college, they often don't know how much they're paying or where exactly the money is coming from. They're in the dark.

What do institutions do about this? Well, that's where it gets a little strange. The world of higher education is a sort of twilight zone where institutions can choose to explain or not explain their real price versus their sticker price, or disclose all the combinations of government and institutional loans, scholarships and grants that students can receive to pay for it.

"There's been a lack of transparency from universities about what the cost of the university is, so we're trying to get some clarity there."

Education Secretary Arne Duncan says that's one reason students are confused.

"I don't think it's in anybody's best interest, let alone the university, for young people to make bad choices," Duncan says.

Borrowing for college, after all, is akin to taking out a mortgage on a house these days. And we all know how that's turned out. You're lending money to lots of people with little or no credit, and no clue about what they've gotten themselves into.

"I didn't realize how much debt I had until I graduated," says Sarah Bickens, a teacher from New York visiting the nation's capital. She remembers all too well the fear that came over her.

"So there's this horrifying moment at the end of your senior year in college when they put everyone in an auditorium, and they give you the piece of paper that says how much money you owe," Bickens says. "There's this collective gasp."

Collective gasp is right. When you add up the total student loan debt out there, it takes your breath away.

"Just over $1 trillion; it's higher than all consumer loan debt combined," says Roger Michaud with the College Savings Foundation. He says growing debt and the student loan default rate are worrisome.

"With just short of 12 million undergrad students enrolled today, two-thirds will leave with debt, some exceeding $100,000, just to complete that four-year degree," Michaud says.

Sure, it all sounds scary, he says: the price of college going up every year; the rising student loan debt; the default rate. But he credits the Obama administration for at least trying to lift the burden on college graduates by capping their monthly payments at 10 percent of discretionary income. And if they've paid their loans on time but 20 years down the road they still owe money, the government will forgive the balance.

"Is it a giveaway? Yeah, forgiving a student loan is a giveaway," Michaud says.

The question, he says, is will it be worth it? Or will it come back to haunt us?

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Figuring out how to pay for college can be a complicate, even mind-boggling experience. As NPR's Claudio Sanchez reports, parents and students struggle to get answers to simple questions. Questions like how much will it cost for four years of college, where to get a loan, and what will I owe at graduation.

CLAUDIO SANCHEZ, BYLINE: Roughly seven out of 10 students borrow money to pay for college, and for many the process might as well be a mystery wrapped in a riddle.

TOM MCWILLIAMS: I wish I knew more. I just haven't really had time to look through everything. I mean I needed the money so I took it anyway.

SANCHEZ: Tom McWilliams, a psychology and computer science major at George Washington University, is paying about $60,000 a year for tuition, room and board.

MCWILLIAMS: Right now I have about 6,000 a semester. I think right now it's all federal.

SANCHEZ: That's unlikely, because the most you can borrow from Uncle Sam is $10,000 a year, which means he's probably borrowing from a private lender and doesn't know it, or he can't tell the difference. In fact, McWilliams isn't entirely sure what types of loans he's taken out: federal, private, subsidized, unsubsidized.

MCWILLIAMS: Actually, I don't remember.

SANCHEZ: McWilliams seems to take some strange pleasure, though, knowing he's not alone.

MCWILLIAMS: This is an expensive school, so a lot of people have debt here. They don't really look too deeply into it, they just take the money.

SANCHEZ: That's the problem. When students get into college, they often don't know how much they're paying or where exactly the money is coming from. They're in the dark.

(SOUNDBITE OF "THE TWILIGHT ZONE" THEME MUSIC)

SANCHEZ: What do institutions do about this? Well, that's where it gets a little strange.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "THE TWILIGHT ZONE")

ROD SERLING: You're traveling through another dimension, a dimension not only of sight and sound but of mind, a journey into a wondrous land whose boundaries are that of imagination. Your next stop, the Twilight Zone.

SANCHEZ: Rod Serling wasn't too far off in describing the world of higher education, where institutions can choose to explain or not explain the real price versus the sticker price, or disclose all the combinations of government and institutional loans, scholarships and grants, students can receive to pay for it.

ARNE DUNCAN: There's been a lack of transparency from universities about what the cost of the university is, so we're trying to get greater clarity there.

SANCHEZ: U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan says that's one reason students are confused.

DUNCAN: I don't think it's in anyone's best interest, let alone the universities, for young people to make bad choices.

SANCHEZ: Borrowing for college, after all, is akin to taking out a mortgage on a house these days. And we all know how that's turned out. You're lending money to lots of people with little or no credit, and no clue about what they've gotten themselves into.

(SOUNDBITE OF SCREAM)

SARAH BICKENS: I didn't realize how much student loan debt I had until I graduated.

SANCHEZ: Sarah Bickens, a school teacher from New York visiting the nation's capital, remembers all too well the fear that came over her.

BICKENS: So there's this horrifying moment at the end of your senior year in college when they put everyone in an auditorium and they give you the piece of paper that says how much money you owe. And there's just like a collective gasp.

SANCHEZ: Collective gasp is right. When you add up the total student loan debt out there, it takes your breath away.

ROGER MICHAUD: Just over $1 trillion. It's higher than all consumer loan debt combined.

SANCHEZ: Roger Michaud is with the College Savings Foundation. He says growing debt and student loan default rates are worrisome.

MICHAUD: With just short of 12 million undergrad students enrolled today, two-thirds of those students will leave with debt, some exceeding $100,000 just to complete that four year degree.

SANCHEZ: Sure, says Michaud, it all sounds scary, the price of college going up every year, the rising student loan debt, the default rate. But he credits the Obama administration for at least trying to lift the burden on college graduates by capping their monthly payments at 10 percent of discretionary income. And if they've paid their loans on time but 20 years down the road they still owe money, the government will forgive the balance.

MICHAUD: Is it a give-way? Yeah, forgiving a direct student loan on a national level is a give-away.

SANCHEZ: The question, says Michaud, is will it be worth it or will it come back to haunt us.

Claudio Sanchez, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.