Education
12:49 am
Tue October 15, 2013

Silicon Valley Trailer Park Residents Fight To Stay

Originally published on Tue October 15, 2013 9:37 am

Sunny Palo Alto, Calif., is awash in multimillion-dollar homes, luxury Tesla electric cars and other financial fruits from a digital revolution the city helped spark. The Silicon Valley city is home to Stanford University, at least eight billionaires, and one mobile home park.

Now, Buena Vista Mobile Home Park — one of the largest and one of the few remaining affordable housing options here — is threatened with closure. The owners want to sell the land to a developer who plans to build luxury apartments for the high-tech corridor's growing workforce. The park's low-income, mostly Latino residents are fighting to stay in their community and to keep their kids in one of California's best school districts.

The fight shows the less-publicized underbelly of Silicon Valley's incredible successes: unequal access to education, and the marginalization of some low-income workers.

A Good Education

"Most of us don't really know where we'd go" if the park closed, says 28-year-old Erika Escalante, who grew up at Buena Vista and now lives in a mobile home there with her husband and 6-year-old son. "With rents in Palo Alto, it's just impossible," she says.

Quality public education is the main reason many of the park's residents are fighting to stay. The Palo Alto schools rank sixth among more than 1,000 districts in the state, and test scores for all ethnic groups have regularly exceeded statewide averages.

Escalante was the first in her family to graduate from college. Her sister and brother are now following her lead. Escalante's dad worked as a janitor. She says he moved the family to Buena Vista largely because of the schools.

"He felt like we were getting the best education that he could possibly offer to us," Escalante says. "I mean, we know that historically Hispanics are kind of disadvantaged. There's that big education gap. And to be able to have access to that education, I mean, you can't put a price there. We want to be able to succeed, you know, kind of like that American dream. Education is a big part of that."

An Airstream To Call Home

Buena Vista is home to more than 400 predominantly low-income residents, more than 80 percent of them Latino.

Ringed with a jumble of potted plants, a silver '70s-era Airstream trailer has been home to Jennifer Tello for most of her 12 years.

"My mom works cleaning houses, and my dad works construction," she says. Jennifer's mom is busy getting food for her baby sister before heading off to work. Jennifer says her parents struggled to find a place in the Bay Area that's safe, affordable and has quality schools.

"They're really good schools. My mom works really hard, and so does my dad. Sometimes they don't have enough time to spend with us. I'm really happy that they're really hard working. And they encourage me to work hard, so I [could] have a better job," she says.

The park's owners, Toufic and Eva Jisser, have petitioned the city of Palo Alto to close shop. They want to sell the land to Prometheus Real Estate Group, which wants to build 180 luxury apartments on the site. "My client has a constitutional right to exit the rental business," says Margaret Ecker Nanda, the owners' lawyer. Prometheus officials declined to comment.

The Value Of Diversity

Jennifer Tello attends a nearby middle school. "I don't want to move and start all over and find new friends," she says.

The PTA, the school board, and some parents have taken action to back the park's residents. They've offered supportive resolutions, organizing space, and their time. Nancy Krop, a civil rights attorney, is one of those parents. She says diversity, fairness and justice are at stake.

"I want every child to have the opportunity that my son's going to have — and that I had," Krop says. These kids at Buena Vista "want the world, and know they need a Palo Alto education to get it."

Krop says she was attending a City Council meeting when one Buena Vista mother spoke up. "She mentioned that she made a living cleaning other peoples' houses. And she asked the City Council to please allow her family to keep their home at the mobile home park because she felt that if her daughter went through the Palo Alto schools, her daughter would not grow up to clean other peoples' homes," says Krop. "I was really struck by that."

Krop's fifth-grade son attends nearby Barron Park Elementary, where 35 percent of the students are Latino and about half the students are learning English. She says the benefits of that diversity are key for her family in a city that is incredibly affluent and still mostly white.

"My son has gone on play dates to homes where he found out his friend didn't have a bedroom. His friend sleeps on a couch. He didn't even know that that was how some kids grow up. You learn what they don't have; you learn the richness of what they do have too — the strength of their community and culture and heritage," she says.

Trying To Stop The Sale

The residents are asking the city to help stop the sale. They point out that city planning documents list the mobile home park as a key source of affordable housing and "encourages its preservation." But ultimately, that may not mean much legally. Palo Alto city attorneys say the mobile home park is not counted as part of a regional affordable housing plan required by the state.

The city has twice rejected the owners' application to close the park, largely due to incomplete details in its relocation benefits package. "There is recognition of the desire to preserve the park," says city spokeswoman Claudia Keith. But with soaring private property values in Silicon Valley, she says there may be little the city can do. The park's residents can appeal any final decision the city makes to an independent hearing officer.

The Buena Vista residents' group, with help from legal aid and affordable housing organizations, offered to buy the property for $14.5 million. The owners rejected that offer.

The owners' attorney Margaret Nanda says her client has every right to cash in on booming property values and retire. The owner was offered more than $30 million for the 4.5-acre lot. "He is not a social agency or a nonprofit. He's a private business operator who wants to sell his property," she says.

Nanda says her client will compensate tenants fairly under city law, but equivalent quality schools are not part of that package. "There is absolutely no right to a Palo Alto education under the [city] ordinance" for converting a mobile home park, Nanda says. "The ordinance says they are to be relocated to comparable housing. And then the ordinance references a number of things, but education is not one of them."

'Squeezed' By Rising Housing Costs

Amado Padilla, a professor at the Stanford Graduate School of Education, has teamed up with the medical school to study the education, housing and health care challenges the Buena Vista residents face. Padilla notes that the residents' struggle highlights a less-discussed part of the valley's thriving high-tech economy: It's driving tremendous job growth, but surging housing prices are forcing more and more working people to the margins.

"Just like police and firemen and also teachers cannot afford to live in Palo Alto, these people could not afford to live in Palo Alto if it were not for places like the mobile park home. Our service workers are getting squeezed in all kinds of directions because of the tech fields in our areas," Padilla says.

Silicon Valley is particularly hard hit by sky-high housing prices. But the problem is serious across large swaths of America's most populous state. New research by the Center on Poverty and Inequality at Stanford says that rising housing costs are pushing more families into poverty. According to the center's new California Poverty Measure, 22 percent of Californians are in poverty.

At a recent potluck dinner celebrating diversity at the Barron Park school, a few blocks from the mobile home park, kids, parents and teachers ate, talked and heard songs and performances.

It's clear the Buena Vista residents are not going away silently. With few resources of their own, they are vowing to fight to stay in the community — and schools — that they love.

But this may all come down to the hard reality of money: Buena Vista residents pay about $700 a month in rent. Palo Alto's average monthly rental is nearly four times that amount. And the average home price here is edging up to nearly $2 million.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

Now let's talk about people at the top of society, and at the bottom, here in the United States. Palo Alto, in California's Silicon Valley is home to eight billionaires and also home to one mobile home park. The owner of that mobile home park wants to sell the land to a developer. The developer plans to build luxury apartments, housing for the upscale workforce in the world's best known technology corridor.

Low income residents of that mobile home park are pushing back. They want to stay and keep their kids in one of California's best school districts. NPR's Eric Westervelt reports.

ERIC WESTERVELT, BYLINE: Jennifer Tello stands next to her family's late 1970s era trailer at the Buena Vista Mobile Home Park. A jumble of potted plants ring the trailer's front. Call it a yard. For most of Jennifer's 12 years, this silver Airstream has been home.

JENNIFER TELLO: My mom works cleaning houses and my dad works for construction.

WESTERVELT: Her parents, she says, struggled to find a place in the Bay area that's safe, affordable, and has strong schools.

TELLO: They're really good schools. My mom works really hard and so does my dad. And they encourage me to work hard so I have a better job.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

The park is home to more than 400 predominantly low income residents, more than 80 percent of them Latino. But the park's owner has petitioned the city to close shop and sell the land to a developer that wants to build 180 luxury apartments. That's upsetting to Jennifer who attends a close by middle school.

TELLO: I don't want to, like, move and start all over and find new friends.

WESTERVELT: Forty-five of the Buena Vista kids attend this elementary school, Barron Park, a few blocks away where second graders are switching math stations.

(SOUNDBITE OF SCHOOL)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Tell me where this is at.

UNIDENTIFIED BOY: On two.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Two. Good.

WESTERVELT: Great public schools is the main reason trailer park residents are fighting to stay. The Palo Alto schools rank sixth among California's more than 1,000 districts and test scores for all ethnic groups exceeded statewide averages. Many parents and members of the PTA and the school board have taken action to support the park's residents. They've offered resolutions, organizing space and their time.

Parent Nancy Krop , an attorney, is one of them.

NANCY KROP: I want every child to have the opportunity that my son is going to have and that I had.

WESTERVELT: Krop was attending a city council meeting when a Buena Vista parent spoke up and made an impact on her.

KROP: She mentioned that she made a living cleaning other peoples' houses. And she asked city council to please allow her family to keep their home at the mobile home park, because she felt that if her daughter went through the Palo Alto schools, her daughter wouldn't grow up to clean other peoples' homes.

WESTERVELT: Krop's fifth grade son attends Barron Park, where 35 percent of the kids are Latino and about half of the overall students don't speak English as a first language. She says the benefits of that diversity are key in wealthy, mostly white Palo Alto.

KROP: And my son has gone on play dates to homes where he found out his friend didn't have a bedroom. His friend sleeps on the couch. He didn't even know that was how some kids grew up. You learn what they don't, you learn the richness of what they do have, too. You know, the strength of their community and culture and heritage.

WESTERVELT: Twenty-eight-year-old Erika Escalante grew up and now lives with her husband and six-year-old son in the mobile home park. She was the first in her family to graduate from college. Her sister and brother are now following her lead. Escalante's dad was a janitor. She says he moved here because of the schools.

ERIKA ESCALANTE: He felt like we were getting the best education he could possibly offer to us. I mean we know that historically Hispanics are kind of like disadvantaged, there's that big education gap. And to be able to have access to that education, I mean you can't put a price there.

WESTERVELT: The residents are asking the city to step in and help stop the sale. They point out that city documents encourage the mobile park's preservation. But that may mean little, legally: the park is not counted as part of state-required affordable housing plan.

Margaret Ecker Nanda is the attorney for the owner of Buena Vista. She says her client has every right to cash in on booming property values and retire. The owner has been offered more than $30 million for the four and a half acre lot. Nanda says her client will compensate tenants fairly under city law, but equivalent quality schools are not part of that package.

MARGARET ECKER NANDA: The ordinance says they are to be relocated to comparable housing. And then the ordinance references a number of things, but education is not one of them.

WESTERVELT: Amado Padilla, a Stanford Education professor, has teamed up with the medical school to study the education, housing and health care challenges the Buena Vista resident's face. Padilla notes that the residents' struggle underscores a less discussed part of the Silicon Valley's thriving high-tech economy: it's driving big job growth, but surging housing prices are forcing more and more working people to the margins.

AMADO PADILLA: These people could not afford to live in Palo Alto if it were not for places like the mobile park home. Our service workers are getting squeezed from all kinds of directions, because of the tech fields in our areas.

(SOUNDBITE OF A CROWD)

WESTERVELT: At Barron Park School at a potluck celebrating the school's diversity, it's clear the Buena Vista Mobile Home Park residents are not going away silently. With few resources of their own, they're vowing to fight to stay in their community and their schools. But this all may come down to the hard reality of money. Buena Vista residents pay an average of $700 a month in rent. Palo Alto's average monthly apartment rental is more than triple that amount. And the average home price here now is nearly $2 million.

Eric Westervelt, NPR News, Palo Alto.

INSKEEP: This is NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.